| 4th Quarter Play-by-Play |
| Heid_3_ | 2-14 | on Musk25 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Heid_3_ | 2-14 | on Musk25 | Kenny Sims rush for 7 yards to the MUSK18 (Dennis Hicks). |
| Heid_3_ | 3-7 | on Musk18 | Andrew Miller pass incomplete to Jozey Hill. |
| Heid_3_ | 4-7 | on Musk18 | Jesse Hawkins field goal attempt from 35 MISSED - wide right, spot at MUSK20, clock 14:09. |
| | Drive: 7 plays, 47 yards, TOP 2:50 |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Musk20 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 14:09. |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Musk20 | Palmer Smith rush for 35 yards to the HEID_3_45, 1ST DOWN MUSK (Fran Cavotta). |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Heid_3_45 | Dwight Sutton rush for loss of 3 yards to the HEID_3_48, out-of-bounds (Andy Fadenholz). |
| Musk | 2-13 | on Heid_3_48 | Jake Burns pass incomplete to D. Bailey, dropped pass. |
| Musk | 3-13 | on Heid_3_48 | D. Bailey rush for 26 yards to the HEID_3_22, 1ST DOWN MUSK (Fran Cavotta;Andy Fadenholz). |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Heid_3_22 | Jake Burns pass incomplete to Palmer Smith, dropped pass. |
| Musk | 2-10 | on Heid_3_22 | Palmer Smith rush for 2 yards to the HEID_3_20 (Chris Bowden;Sam Driscoll). |
| Musk | 3-8 | on Heid_3_20 | Jake Burns sacked for loss of 5 yards to the HEID_3_25 (Matt Grieves). |
| Musk | 4-13 | on Heid_3_25 | Jake Burns pass incomplete to Blake Allen, QB hurry by Matt Grieves. |
| | Drive: 8 plays, 55 yards, TOP 3:34 |
| Heid_3_ | 1-10 | on Heid_3_25 | HEIDELBERG drive start at 10:35. |
| Heid_3_ | 1-10 | on Heid_3_25 | Jemar Lewis rush for 7 yards to the HEID_3_32 (Dennis Hicks;Chad Bajc). |
| Heid_3_ | 2-3 | on Heid_3_32 | Jemar Lewis rush for 4 yards to the HEID_3_36, 1ST DOWN HEID_3_ (James Beatty). |
| Heid_3_ | 1-10 | on Heid_3_36 | Andrew Miller pass incomplete to Mitch White, dropped pass. |
| Heid_3_ | 2-10 | on Heid_3_36 | Andrew Miller pass complete to Mike Preston for 34 yards to the MUSK30, 1ST DOWN HEID_3_ (CJ McArthur). |
| Heid_3_ | 1-10 | on Musk30 | Timeout Heidelberg, clock 08:54. |
| Heid_3_ | 1-10 | on Musk30 | Jemar Lewis rush for 6 yards to the MUSK24, out-of-bounds (Darrel Henley). |
| Heid_3_ | 2-4 | on Musk24 | Andrew Miller pass complete to Mario Walton for 18 yards to the MUSK6, 1ST DOWN HEID_3_ (Alex Thomas), PENALTY MUSK face mask 3 yards to the MUSK3, 1ST DOWN HEID_3_. |
| Heid_3_ | 1-G | on Musk03 | 1st and 3. |
| Heid_3_ | 1-G | on Musk03 | Jemar Lewis rush for loss of 1 yard to the MUSK4 (Rob Premdas;CJ McArthur). |
| Heid_3_ | 2-G | on Musk04 | Andrew Miller pass complete to Mitch White for 4 yards to the MUSK0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:11. |
| | | Jesse Hawkins kick attempt good. |
| Muskingum 24, Heidelberg 21 |
| | Drive: 8 plays, 75 yards, TOP 3:24 |
| | | Jesse Hawkins kickoff 35 yards to the MUSK35, out-of-bounds, PENALTY HEID_3_ illegal procedure 5 yards to the MUSK40, 1st and 10, MUSK ball on MUSK40. |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Musk40 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 07:11. |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Musk40 | Palmer Smith rush for 8 yards to the MUSK48 (J. Higginbotham). |
| Musk | 2-2 | on Musk48 | Antowan Logan rush for 3 yards to the HEID_3_49, 1ST DOWN MUSK (Wayne Glisson;Matt Grieves). |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Heid_3_49 | Palmer Smith rush for 3 yards to the HEID_3_46 (Andy Fadenholz;Chris Hogan). |
| Musk | 2-7 | on Heid_3_46 | Jake Burns rush for loss of 1 yard to the HEID_3_47 (Matt Grieves). |
| Musk | 3-8 | on Heid_3_47 | Jake Burns rush for 9 yards to the HEID_3_38, 1ST DOWN MUSK (Jacob Mitchell). |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Heid_3_38 | Antowan Logan rush for 2 yards to the HEID_3_36 (J. Higginbotham). |
| Musk | 2-8 | on Heid_3_36 | Antowan Logan rush for loss of 6 yards to the HEID_3_42 (Sam Driscoll), PENALTY HEID_3_ personal foul 15 yards to the HEID_3_27, 1ST DOWN MUSK. |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Heid_3_27 | 1st and 10. |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Heid_3_27 | Palmer Smith rush for 2 yards to the HEID_3_25 (Chris Bowden;Jared Ruffing). |
| Musk | 2-8 | on Heid_3_25 | Jake Burns rush for 10 yards to the HEID_3_15, 1ST DOWN MUSK (Jared Ruffing). |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Heid_3_15 | Jake Burns rush for 15 yards to the HEID_3_0, 1ST DOWN MUSK, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:28, PENALTY HEID_3_ personal foul 0 yards to the HEID_3_3. |
| | | Bill Rini kick attempt good. |
| Muskingum 31, Heidelberg 21 |
| Musk | 1-G | on Musk30 | 1st and 10. |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Musk30 | MUSK ball on MUSK45. |
| | Drive: 10 plays, 60 yards, TOP 5:43 |
| | | Bill Rini kickoff 48 yards to the HEID_3_7, Kenny Sims return 33 yards to the HEID_3_40 (Joe Shafer), PENALTY HEID_3_ illegal block 30 yards to the HEID_3_10, 1st and 10, HEID_3_ ball on HEID_3_10. |
| Heid_3_ | 1-10 | on Heid_3_10 | HEIDELBERG drive start at 01:19. |
| Heid_3_ | 1-10 | on Heid_3_10 | Andrew Miller pass complete to Mario Walton for 43 yards to the MUSK47, 1ST DOWN HEID_3_. |
| Heid_3_ | 1-10 | on Musk47 | PENALTY HEID_3_ false start 5 yards to the HEID_3_48. |
| Heid_3_ | 1-15 | on Heid_3_48 | Andrew Miller pass complete to Mike Preston for 45 yards to the MUSK7, 1ST DOWN HEID_3_ (Dennis Hicks). |
| Heid_3_ | 1-G | on Musk07 | Timeout Heidelberg, clock 00:48. |
| Heid_3_ | 1-G | on Musk07 | Andrew Miller rush for loss of 2 yards to the MUSK9, out-of-bounds (Alex Thomas). |
| Heid_3_ | 2-G | on Musk09 | Andrew Miller rush for loss of 3 yards to the MUSK12 (Rob Premdas;Ethan Wetzel). |
| Heid_3_ | 3-G | on Musk12 | Timeout Heidelberg, clock 00:32. |
| Heid_3_ | 3-G | on Musk12 | Andrew Miller pass complete to Mike Preston for 12 yards to the MUSK0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:28. |
| | | Jesse Hawkins kick attempt good. |
| Muskingum 31, Heidelberg 28 |
| | Drive: 5 plays, 90 yards, TOP 0:51 |
| | | Jesse Hawkins kickoff 18 yards to the HEID_3_48, out-of-bounds, MUSK ball on HEID_3_49. |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Heid_3_49 | MUSKINGUM drive start at 00:24. |
| Musk | 1-10 | on Heid_3_49 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the 50 yardline. |
| Musk | 2-11 | on Musk50 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | Drive: 1 play, minus 1 yard, TOP 0:24 |
